Наши индексы цитирования:
ЕВРОПЕЙСКИЕ ПРАВОВЫЕ СТАНДАРТЫ ДОКАЗЫВАНИЯ И ОЦЕНКИ ДОКАЗАТЕЛЬСТВ
ЕВРОПЕЙСКИЕ ПРАВОВЫЕ СТАНДАРТЫ ДОКАЗЫВАНИЯ
И ОЦЕНКИ ДОКАЗАТЕЛЬСТВ
А.Р. СУЛТАНОВ,
начальник юридического управления ОАО «Нижнекамскнефтехим»,
член Ассоциации по улучшению жизни и образования (ABLE)
DOI: 10.24031/2226-0781-2019-9-1-96-113
Влияние европейских правовых стандартов сказывается на развитии процес-
суального законодательства, и данное явление имеет место в судебной власти,
несмотря на то, что она является наиболее консервативной ветвью власти
(что характерно не только для России, но и для других стран, принадлежащих
к иным системам права). Законодателями и правоприменителями страны в пол-
ной мере должны учитываться правовые позиции Европейского суда по правам
человека – это позволит предупредить возникновение многих нарушений Кон-
венции о защите прав человека и основных свобод, в частности рассмотрение
вопросов об ограничении прав и свобод должно обеспечиваться надлежащей пра-
вовой процедурой, которая в себя включает гарантии возможности участво-
вать в процессе доказывания. Статья посвящена анализу европейских правовых
стандартов доказывания и оценки доказательств. По мнению автора, подходы
и правовые позиции ЕСПЧ к восприятию справедливости судопроизводства обыч-
но не вызывают сомнений, однако когда речь идет о толковании национального
материального права, возможны различные ситуации. В статье приводятся раз-
личные примеры постановлений Пленума ВС РФ, мнения исследователей и при-
меры из судебной практики.
Ключевые слова: доказывание; оценка доказательств; стандарты; Европейский суд
по правам человека; Конвенция о защите прав человека и основных свобод; граж-
данский процесс.
References
Afanasyev S.F. Pravo na spravedlivoe sudebnoe razbiratel’stvo: teoretiko-prakticheskoe
issledovanie vliyaniya Evropejskoj Konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod
na rossijskoe grazhdanskoe sudoproizvodstvo: Dis. … dokt. yurid. nauk [The Right to
a Fair Trial: A Theoretical and Practical Study of the Impact of the Convention for the
Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms in Russian Civil Proceedings:
Thesis for a Doctor Degree in Law Sciences]. Saratov, 2010. (In Russian)
Berestnev Yu.Yu. (ed.). Evropejskij sud po pravam cheloveka i Rossijskaya Federatsiya:
postanovleniya i resheniya, vynesennye do 1 marta 2004 g. [European Court of Human
Rights and the Russian Federation: Judgments and Decisions Issued Before 1 March
2004]. Moscow, 2005. (In Russian)
Fokina M.A. (ed.). Kurs dokazatel’stvennogo prava: Grazhdanskij protsess. Arbitrazhnyj
protsess [Course of Evidence: Civil Procedure. Arbitration Procedure]. Moscow,
2014. (In Russian)
Fursov D.A. Poryadok rassmotreniya del ob ustanovlenii fakta ekstremistskoj napravlennosti
rasprostranyaemoj informatsii [The Order of Consideration of Cases on the
Establishment of the Fact of the Extremist Orientation of the Information Disseminated].
Rossijskoe pravosudie = Russian Justice, 2012, no. 7. (In Russian)
Glazkova M.E. Primenenie evropejskikh standartov otpravleniya pravosudiya v rossijskom
arbitrazhnom protsesse [Application of European Standards of Administration of
Justice in Russian Arbitration Procedure]. Moscow, 2012. (In Russian)
Iodkovsky E.V. Resheniya Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka v grazhdanskom
sudoproizvodstve: Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Decisions of the European Court of Human
Rights in Civil Proceedings: Thesis for a Candidate Degree in Law Sciences]. Moscow,
2014. (In Russian)
Kornilina A.A. Vliyanie postanovlenij Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka na
rossijskoe zakonodatel’stvo i pravoprimenitel’nuyu praktiku: Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk
[Impact of European Court of Human Rights Judgments on Russian Legislation and
Law Enforcement Practice: Thesis for a Candidate Degree in Law Sciences]. Moscow,
2003. (In Russian)
Mashkova K.V. Ispolnenie postanovlenij Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka
v grazhdanskom i arbitrazhnom protsessakh: Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Execution of
Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights in Civil and Arbitration Procedure:
Thesis for a Candidate Degree in Law Sciences]. Moscow, 2014. (In Russian)
Mikheenkova M.A. Nekotorye aspekty vliyaniya Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka
na razvitie rossijskogo dokazatel’stvennogo prava [Some Aspects of the Influence
of the European Court of Human Rights on the Development of Russian Law of Evidence].
Sud’ya = Judge, 2017, no. 2. (In Russian)
Nakhova E.A. Printsip svobodnoj otsenki dokazatel’stv v sisteme printsipov
dokazatel’stvennogo prava v grazhdanskom sudoproizvodstve [The Principle of Free Evaluation
of Evidence in the System of Principles of Evidence in Civil Proceedings]. Leningradskij
yuridicheskij zhurnal = Leningrad Law Journal, 2015, no. 1. (In Russian)
Sadchikova O.V Resheniya Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka i ikh znachenie
dlya rossijskoj pravoprimenitel’noj praktiki: Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Decisions of the
European Court of Human Rights and Their Significance for Russian Law Enforcement
Practice: Thesis for a Candidate Degree in Law Sciences]. Moscow, 2009. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Bezuslovnoe bezobrazie, ili yavlyaetsya li polnoe kopirovanie teksta vozrazhenij
dopustimym v kachestve sudebnogo resheniya? [Undoubted Disgrace, or Is Full
Copying of the Text of Objections Acceptable as a Court Decision?]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo
protsessa = Herald of Civil Procedure, 2017, no. 5. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Bor’ba za pravo na obzhalovanie sudebnogo resheniya [Fight for the
Right to Appeal a Court Decision]. Moscow, 2014. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Dolzhnaya pravovaya protsedura i pravovye standarty Evropejskogo
Suda po pravam cheloveka [Due Process and Legal Standards of the European Court of
Human Rights]. Evrazijskaya advokatura = Eurasian Bar, 2013, no. 1(2). (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Evropejskie pravovye standarty, uroki istorii i pravoprimenitel’naya
praktika [European Legal Standards, History Lessons and Law Enforcement Practice].
Moscow, 2012. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Evropejskie standarty v grazhdanskom sudoproizvodstve na primere
problemy «ekstremistskikh del» [European Standards in Civil Proceedings on the Example
of the Problem of “Extremism Cases”]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo protsessa = Herald of
Civil Procedure, 2011, no. 1. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Formalizm grazhdanskogo protsessa i standarty spravedlivogo pravosudiya
[Formalism of Civil Procedure and Standards of Fair Justice]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo
protsessa = Herald of Civil Procedure, 2012, no. 3. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Implementatsiya Postanovlenij ESPCh i o nekotorykh posledstviyakh
Postanovleniya Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 14 iyulya 2015 g. N 21-P [The Implementation
of Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights and on Some Consequences
of the Judgment of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of 14 July 2015
No. 21-P]. In Tumanov D.A., Zakharova M.V. (eds.). Sluzhenie pravu. Pamyati professora
V.A. Tumanova posvyashchaetsya: Sbornik statej [Serving the Law. In memory of
Professor V.A. Tumanov: Collection of Articles]. Moscow, 2017. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Kopipast kak otkaz v pravosudii [Copypast as a Denial of Justice].
Evrazijskaya advokatura = Eurasian Bar, 2017, no. 5. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Motivirovannost’ sudebnogo akta kak odna iz osnovnykh problem
spravedlivogo pravosudiya [Motivation of the Judicial Act as One of the Main Problems
of Fair Justice]. Zakon = Law, 2014, no. 8. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. O nekotorykh protsessual’nykh posledstviyakh postanovlenij ESPCh
[On Some Procedural Consequences of Judgments of the European Court of Human
Rights]. Rossijskaya yustitsiya = Russian Justice, 2014, no. 1. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. O probleme motivirovannosti sudebnykh aktov cherez prizmu postanovlenij
Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka [On the Problem of Motivation of Judicial Acts
Through the Prism of Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights]. Mezhdunarodnoe
publichnoe i chastnoe pravo = International Public and Private Law, 2008, no. 2. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Pravosudie ne mozhet byt’ nemotivirovannym! [Justice Can Not Be
Unmotivated!]. Zakon = Law, 2018, no. 1. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Pravovaya opredelyonnost’ – chast’ dolzhnoj pravovoj protsedury ili kak
v zakon ob ekstremizme pravovuyu opredelennost’ vvodili [Legal Certainty is a Part of
Due Process of Law or, as in the Law on Extremism, Legal Certainty Was Introduced].
Advokat = Advocate, 2015, no. 1. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Pravovye posledstviya postanovlenij Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka
v grazhdanskom protsesse [Legal Consequences of Judgments of the European Court
of Human Rights in Civil Procedure]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo i mezhdunarodnye organizatsii
= International Law and International Organizations, 2010, no. 3. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Pravovye posledstviya postanovlenij Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka
[Legal Consequences of Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights].
Zhurnal rossijskogo prava = Journal of Russian Law, 2011, no. 9(177). (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Priznanie ekstremistskim materialom smyslovogo perevoda Korana
i voprosy dolzhnoj pravovoj protsedury [Recognition of Semantic Translation of the
Quran as an Extremist Material and Issues of Due Process]. Advokat = Lawyer, 2013,
no. 11. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Protsessy ob ogranichenii svobody vyrazheniya mnenij i svobody sovesti,
uroki istorii i evropejskie standarty [Restrictions on Freedom of Expression and Freedom
of Conscience, History Lessons and European Standards]. Advokat = Lawyer,
2010, no. 10. (In Russian)
Sultanov A.R. Tsenzurnoe proshloe i sovremennaya karatel’naya tsenzura religioznykh
uchenij [Censorship Past and Modern Punitive Censorship of Religious Teachings].
Advokat = Lawyer, 2012, no. 7. (In Russian)
Vorontsova I.V., Solovyeva T.V. Postanovleniya Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka
v grazhdanskom protsesse Rossijskoj Federatsii [Judgments of the European Court
of Human Rights in Civil Procedure of the Russian Federation]. Moscow, 2010. (In
Russian)
Voskobitova M.R. (ed.). Standarty Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka i rossijskaya
pravoprimenitel’naya praktika: Sb. analiticheskikh st. [Standards of the European
Court of Human Rights and Russian Law Enforcement Practice: Collection of Analytical
Articles]. Moscow, 2005. (In Russian)
Zakarlyuka A.V., Zvyagintseva L.M., Kulikova M.A., Malov A.A., Pankratova N.A.,
Reshetnikova I.V., Solomeina E.A., Tsaregorodtseva E.A.; Reshetnikova I.V. (ed.). Spravochnik
po dokazyvaniyu v grazhdanskom sudoproizvodstve [Handbook of Evidence in
Civil Proceedings]. 6th ed. Moscow, 2017. (In Russian)
Zesmkova S.I. Sudebnaya ekspertiza diffamatsionnykh materialov [Forensic Examination
of Defamation Materials]. Moscow, 2013. (In Russian)
Information about the author
Sultanov A.R. (Nizhnekamsk, Russia) – Head of the Legal Department of the
PJSC “Nizhnekamskneftekhim”, Member of Association for Better Living and Edication
(ABLE) (PJSC “Nizhnekamskneftekhim”, Nizhnekamsk, 423574, Russia; e-mail:
Recommended citation
Sultanov A.R. Evropejskie pravovye standarty dokazyvaniya i otsenki dokazatel’stv
[European Legal Standards for Evidence and Evaluation of Evidence]. Вестник граж-
данского процесса = Herald of Civil Procedure, 2019, no. 1, p. 96–113. (In Russian)
DOI: 10.24031/2226-0781-2019-9-1-96-113
А.Р. СУЛТАНОВ
Реклама
Наши партнеры
