Herald of Civil Procedure
EN
main-photo

We in a citing index:

Meaning of Cancellation of the Arbitration Decision by the Court of Its Placement for the Court of the Place of Recognition and Implementation

D.G. GOLSKIY, 
Postgraduate Student of the Department of Civil Procedure 
of the Law Faculty of the Lomonosov 
Moscow State University 

The effect of setting aside of the arbitration award by the court of the place of origin remains a “white spot” in the sphere of regulation of international commercial arbitration. Questions about whether the annulment is of the absolute value for the recognizing and enforcing court, and what, in this case, happens to an award is still controversial. The UN Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (New York, June 10, 1958) does not provide for specific mechanisms for implementing the rules on the award be set aside by the court of its place of issuance. The author reveals two existing approaches to determining the importance of judicial control in the place of arbitration over the arbitration itself and provides examples of judicial practice. In this article, the author questions the common thesis that the set aside award is ceased to exist, and the court of the place of arbitration exercises the “primary” control over the arbitration. Summarizing, in the opinion of the author, the obvious consequences of the cancellation of the arbitral award are not so clear in practice and this issue requires detailed consideration. 

Keywords: arbitration; annulment of arbitral awards; grounds for annulment of awards; consequences of annulment; international standards of annulment; local standards of annulment.

References

Gaillard Е. The Enforcement of Awards Set Aside in the Country of Origin. ICSID Review, 1999, no. 16, p. 16–45.

Karabel’nikov B.R. Ispolnenie i osparivanie reshenij mezhdunarodnyh kommercheskih arbitrazhej. Kommentarij k N’yu-Yorkskoj konventsii 1958 g. i glavam 30 i 31 APK RF 2002 g. [Execution and Contestation of Decisions of International Commercial Arbitration.
Comment on the New-York Convention of 1958 and Chapters 30, 31 of the Arbitration Procedure Code of the Russian Federation 2002]. Moscow, 2008. (In Russian)

Lebedev S.N.; Muranov A.I. (comp.). Izbrannye trudy po mezhdunarodnomu kommercheskomu arbitrazhu, pravu mezhdunarodnoj torgovli, mezhdunarodnomu chastnomu pravu, chastnomu morskomu pravu [Selected Works on International Commercial Arbitration, Law of International Trade, Private International Law, Maritime Private Law]. Moscow, 2009. (In Russian)

Mann F.A. The UNCITRAL Model Law – Lex Facit Arbitrum. Arbitration International, 1986, vol. 2(3), p. 241–261.

Paulsson J. Enforcing Arbitral Awards Notwithstanding a Local Standard Annulment (LSA). The ICC International Court of Arbitration Bulletin, 1998, vol. 9(1), p. 14–31.

Reisman W.M. Systems of Control in International Adjudication and Arbitration: Breakdown and Repair. Duke University Press, 1992.

Scherer M. Effects of Foreign Judgments Relating to International Arbitral Awards: Is the “Judgment Route” the Wrong Road? Journal of International Dispute Settlement, 2013, vol. 4(3), p. 587–628.

Van den Berg A.J. Enforcement of Annulled Awards? The ICC International Court of Arbitration Bulletin, 1998, vol. 9(2), p. 15–21.

Van den Berg A.J. Enforcement of Arbitral Awards Annulled in Russia. Case Comment on Court of Appeal of Amsterdam, April 28, 2009. Journal of International Arbitration, 2010, vol. 27(2), p. 179–198.

Information about the author

Golskiy D.G. (Moscow, Russia) – Postgraduate Student of the Department of Civil Procedure of the Law Faculty of the Lomonosov Moscow State University (119991, GSP-1, Moscow, Leninskie Gory, 1, bldg. 13 (4th educational building), rooms 404A, 405A; e-mail: [email protected]).

Recommended citation

Golskiy D.G. Znachenie otmeny arbitrazhnogo resheniya sudom mesta ego vyneseniya dlya suda mesta priznaniya i privedeniya v ispolnenie [Meaning of Cancellation of the Arbitration Decision by the Court of Its Placement for the Court of the Place of Recognition and Implementation]. Вестник гражданского процесса = Herald of Civil Procedure, 2017, no. 4, p. 184–194. (In Russian) DOI: 10.24031/2226-0781-2017-7-4-184-194

 el_.png   it_.png   book.png

D.G. Golskiy