Herald of Civil Procedure

We in a citing index:

To the Problem of Substantial Procedural Errors or Unconditional Grounds for Reversal of Judgments in Civil Cases

S.F. Afanasiev, 
Doctor of Legal Sciences, Professor of the Department of Civil Procedure 
of the Saratov State Law Academy, Judge in Retirement

In the article, in the light of the historical context, the problem of substantial procedural errors or unconditional grounds for reversal of judgments in civil cases is analyzed. It is noted that for a long period of history countries of the Roman-Germanic legal family are searching for such substantial procedural deviations that would always and unequivocally indicate the insignificance of judicial proceedings, as well as of a judgment in the civil case. Such a search is peculiar for Russia, where this problem was studied and studied comprehensively, namely in terms of links and relations of substantial procedural errors with the authority of the court of second instance, which currently can operate in full and part of the appeal. In general, it is concluded that it is necessary to increase the resistance of material legal relationship to less substantial procedural errors, otherwise the appellate court has to overrule decisions by duplicating their resolute content without changes in their decisions. As for the truly weighty procedural errors, then it is necessary to apply a differentiated legislative approach to them: some can be corrected by using the full appeal, the other should cause the transfer of the case to the court of first instance.

Keywords: court; civil procedure; substantial procedural error; unconditional ground for reversal of a judgment; nullity of the process; the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation; the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.


Dozhdev D.V. Rimskoe chastnoe pravo [Roman Private Law]. Moscow, 2004, p. 246. (In Russian)

Biblija [Bible]. Moscow, 2009, p. 918. (In Russian)

Bratkin D.A. Upotreblenie ἀσφάλεια v papirusah i ego znachenie dlja interpretatsii [The Use of Ἀσφάλεια in the Papyri and Its Importance for the Interpretation]. In Indoevropejskoe jazykoznanie i klassicheskaja filologija: Materialy chtenij, posvjashchen- nyh pamjati I.M. Tronskogo – XIII [Indo-European Linguistics and Classical Philolo- gy: Materials of the Conference, Dedicated to the Memory of I.M. Tronsky – XIII]. St. Petersburg, 2009, pp. 84–85. (In Russian)

Pokrovskij I.A. Istorija rimskogo prava [The History of Roman Law]. Minsk, 2002, p. 204. (In Russian)

Horunzhij S.N. Stanovlenie i razvitie instituta zakonnoj sily sudebnogo reshenija [For- mation and Development of the Institute of Legal Force of the Judgment]. Obrazovanie i pravo = Education and Law, 2012, no. 12, p. 277. (In Russian)

Garrido M.H.G. Rimskoe chastnoe pravo: kazusy, iski, instituty [Roman Private Law: Incidents, Claims, Institutions]. Moscow, 2005, pp. 210–211. (In Russian)

Sud i sud’i v izbrannyh fragmentah iz Digest Justiniana [The Court and Judges in Selected Fragments of Justinian’s Digest]. Moscow, 2006, pp. 701. (In Russian)

Milovidov N.A. Zakonnaja sila sudebnyh reshenij po delam grazhdanskim [Validity of Judgments in Civil Cases]. Yaroslavl’, 1875, pp. 9–10. (In Russian)

Dzhanshiev G. Osnovy sudebnoj reformy (k 25-letiju novogo suda). Istoriko-jurid- icheskie jetjudy [Fundamentals of the Judicial Reform (to the 25th Anniversary of the New Court). Historical and Legal Studies]. Moscow, 1891. (In Russian)

Borisova E.A. Apelljatsija v grazhdanskom (arbitrazhnom) protsesse [Appeals in Civ- il (Arbitration) Process]. Moscow, 2000, p. 32. (In Russian)

Jengel’man I.E. Uchebnik russkogo grazhdanskogo sudoproizvodstva [Textbook of Russian Civil Proceedings]. Jur’ev, 1904, p. 355. (In Russian)

Pobedonostsev K.P. Sudebnoe rukovodstvo. Sbornik pravil, polozhenij i primerov, izvlechennyh iz teorii i praktiki grazhdanskogo sudoproizvodstva [Judicial Management. Collection of Rules, Regulations and Examples Drawn from the Theory and Practice of Civil Proceedings]. St. Petersburg, 1872, p. 444. (In Russian)

Nosenko D.A. Ustav grazhdanskogo sudoproizvodstva. Proizvodstvo grazhdanskih del v obshchih sudebnyh ustanovlenijah [Charter of Civil Procedure. Production of Civil Cases in General Courts of Justice]. Moscow, 1894, p. 201. (In Russian)

Kohmanskij R. Voprosy grazhdanskogo prava i protsessa, razreshennye nasheju apell- jatsionnoju praktikoj [Issues of Civil Law and Process Allowed by Our Appellate Prac- tice]. Kishinev, 1875, vol. I, pp. 4–5. (In Russian)

Gordon V.M. Ustav grazhdanskogo sudoproizvodstva s sistematizirovannym sobrani- em zakonodatel’nyh motivov ko vsem uzakonenijam i raz’jasnenij Pravitel’stvujushchego Senata i Ministerstva Justitsii [Charter of Civil Procedure with the Systematic Collection of Legislative Motives to All Legitimations and Clarifications of the Governing Senate and the Ministry of Justice]. St. Petersburg, 1914, p. 584. (In Russian)

Buckovskij N.A. Ocherk kassatsionnogo porjadka otmeny reshenij po sudebnym usta- vam 1864 g. [The Sketch of Cassation Court Decisions on the Abolition of Statutes in 1864]. St. Petersburg, 1866. (In Russian)

Gordon V.M. Iski o priznanii [Claims for Recognition]. Jaroslavl’, 1906, pp. 149– 150. (In Russian)

Isachenko V.L. Russkoe grazhdanskoe sudoproizvodstvo [Russian Civil Proceedings]. Minsk, 1901, vol. I, p. 149. (In Russian)

Zajtsev I.M. Ustranenie sudebnyh oshibok v grazhdanskom protsesse [Elimination of Miscarriages of Justice in Civil Proceedings]. Saratov, 1985, p. 28. (In Russian)

Borisova E.A. Proverka sudebnyh aktov po grazhdanskim delam [Verification of Judi- cial Decisions in Civil Cases]. Moscow, 2006, pp. 101–102. (In Russian)

Shakir’janov R.V. Osnovanija napravlenija grazhdanskih del sudami apelljatsionnoj instantsii na novoe rassmotrenie mirovym sud’jam [Grounds for the Transfer of Civil Cases by Courts of Appeal Court for a New Trial to the Magistrates]. Rossijskaja Justitsija = Russian Justice, 2010, no. 10, pp. 30–33. (In Russian)

Terehova L.A. Sistema peresmotra sudebnyh reshenij v GPK RF [The System of Review of Judicial Decisions in the Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation]. Vestnik Grazhdanskogo Protsessa = Herald of Civil Procedure, 2012, no. 3, p. 35. (In Russian)

Osokina G.L. Grazhdanskij protsess. Osobennaja chast’ [Civil Proceedings. Special Part]. Moscow, 2007, p. 672. (In Russian)

Kalinkina L.D. K voprosu o sudebnyh reshenijah, vynosimyh sudom apelljatsionnoj instantsii [To the Issue of Judicial Decisions Handed Down by the Appellate Court]. In Apelljatsija: realii, tendentsii i perspektivy [Appeal: Realities, Trends and Prospects]. Nizhnij Novgorod, 2013, pp. 65–66. (In Russian)

Zhilin G.A. (ed.). Kommentarij k Grazhdanskomu protsessual’nomu kodeksu RF (postatejnyj) [Commentary on the Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation (Itemized)]. Moscow, 2003. p. 649. (In Russian)

Zhilin G.A. (ed.). Kommentarij k Arbitrazhnomu protsessual’nomu kodeksu RF (postatejnyj) [Commentary on the Arbitration Procedure Code of the Russian Federation (Itemized)]. Moscow, 2009, p. 659. (In Russian)

Afanas’ev S.F. Pravo na spravedlivoe sudebnoe razbiratel’stvo: teoretiko-prakticheskoe issledovanie vlijanija Evropejskoj Konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnyh svobod na rossijskoe grazhdanskoe sudoproizvodstvo [The Right to a Fair Trial: Theoretical and Practical Study of the Influence of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms on Russian Civil Proceedings]: Abstract of Dissertation ... Doctor of Legal Sciences. Saratov, 2010, pp. 31–33. (In Russian)

Shirvindt A.M. Znachenie fiktsii v rimskom prave [The Value of Fiction in Roman Law]. Moscow, 2013. (In Russian)

Shakir’janov R.V. O desjati pravilah rassmotrenija grazhdanskih del po pravilam proizvodstva v sude pervoj instantsii bez ucheta osobennostej apelljatsionnogo proizvodstva s kommentarijami sudebnoj praktiki, formirujushchejsja v rabote sudov obshchej jurisdiktsii [About Ten Rules of Civil Proceedings by Rules of the Court of First Instance without Taking into Account Features of Appellate Jurisprudence with Commentary of the Judicial Practice, Emerging in Courts of General Jurisdiction]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo protsessa = Herald of Civil Procedure, 2014, no. 2, p. 49. (In Russian)

Information about the author

Afanasiev S.F. (Saratov) – Doctor of Legal Sciences, Professor of the Department of Civil Procedure of the Saratov State Law Academy, Judge in Retirement (410056, Saratov, Chernyshevsky st., 104, Department of Civil Procedure of the Saratov State Law Academy; e-mail: af.73@mail.ru).

 el_.png   it_.png   book.png

S.F. Afanasiev