Herald of Civil Procedure
EN
main-photo

We in a citing index:

Revisiting the Counter-Claiming in the Court of Appeal

The article discusses issues related to the counter-claiming in the appellate courts. The court considering the matter, gives one answer to the plaintiff’s claim by its decision. Response of the court on a substantive claim of the plaintiff contains also an answer to the plaintiff’s appeal to the court to protect his rights. Counterclaim is also a procedural remedies; to him, as a special case of an action in general, relates all that relates to the original claim. The possibility of filing a counterclaim in the court of second instance, the introduction of this type of appeal proceedings raises the doctrine challenged to make certain changes to the classical definition of the counterclaim. Given that the adoption of the counterclaim leads to the proper consideration of the case, the final resolution of the current conflict between the parties, legislators should provide measures that would interest the courts, persons involved in the case, for counter-claiming, allowing a counterclaim to proceed, its resolution together with the original claim. Suggests ways to further improve and optimize the institution of counterclaim in the court of second instance. 

Keywords: appellate court; claim; counterclaim; complete appeal; incomplete appeal.

References
 
  Avdeenko N.I. Isk i ego vidy v sovetskom grazhdanskom protsesse [The Action and Its Kinds in the Soviet Civil Procedure]: Dissertation ... Candidate of Legal Sciences. Leningrad, 1950, p. 125. (In Russian) 
  Dobrovol’sky A.A., Ivanova S.A. Osnovnye problemy iskovoi formy zashchity prava [The Main Problems of the Claim Form of Right Protection]. Moscow, 1979. (In Russian) 
   Kleinman A.F. Osnovnye voprosy ucheniya ob iske v sovetskom grazhdanskom protsessual’nom prave [The Main Issues of the Doctrine of Claim in the Soviet Civil Procedural Law]. Moscow, 1959, p. 23. (In Russian) Popov V.V. Pravo na vstrechnyi isk [The Right to Counterclaim]. Yuridicheskii mir = Juridical world, 2007, no. 12, p. 30. (In Russian) 
   Klein N.I. Vstrechnyi isk v sude i arbitrazhe [Counterclaim in Court and Arbitration Court]. Moscow, 1964, p. 12. (In Russian) 
   Patsatsiya M.Sh., Prikhod’ko I.A. Vstrechnyi isk v arbitrazhnom protsesse [Counterclaim in the Arbitration Procedure], Khozyastvo i pravo = Economy and Law, 2000, no. 8, p. 20. (In Russian) 
   Fursov D.A. Predmet, sistema i osnovnye printsipy arbitrazhnogo protsessual’nogo prava [Object, System, and the Basic Principles of Arbitration Procedural Law]. Moscow, 1999, p. 309. (In Russian) 
   Popov V.V. Vstrechnyi isk: sochetanie protsessual’nykh printsipov i mezhdunarodnykh norm [Counterclaim: A Combination of Procedural Principles and International Rules]. Arbitrazhnyi i grazhdanskii protsess = Arbitration and Civil Procedure, 2005, no. 10, p. 17. (In Russian) 
  Bychkov A. Vstretit’ isk vstrechnym iskom [Meet the Claim by Counterclaim]. ezh- Yurist = ej-Lawyer, 2013, no. 20, p. 8. (In Russian) 
  Nechaev V.I. (ed.). Kommentarii k Grazhdanskomu protsessual’nomu kodeksu Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Commentary on the Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation]. Moscow, 2013, p. 284. (In Russian) 
   Laskina N.V. Sudebnye opredeleniya, vynosimye pri nesoblyudenii uslovii prinyatiya vstrechnogo iska, i vozmozhnosti ikh obzhalovaniya [Judicial Decrees Rendered by Non- Compliance with the Conditions of Acceptance of the Counterclaim, and the Possibility of Their Appeal]. Nalogi (gazeta) = Taxes (newspaper), 2011, no. 12. (In Russian) 
  Budak E.V. Apellyatsionnoe proizvodstvo v Rossii i Avstrii [Appeal Proceedings in Russia and Austria]. Moscow, 2010, p. 73. (In Russian) 
   Larina N.V. Vstrechnyi isk v arbitrazhnom protsesse [Counterclaim in the Arbitration Procedure]. Zhurnal rossiiskogo prava = Journal of Russian Law, 2004, no. 8, p. 26. (In Russian) 
  Dergachev S.A. Vstrechnyi isk i dogovornaya podsudnost’: vopros sootnosheniya [Counterclaim and Contractual Jurisdiction: The Question of Correlation]. Rossiiskii sudya = Russian Judge, 2010, no. 8, p. 18. (In Russian) 
  Zhilin G.A. Pravosudie po grazhdanskim delam: aktual’nye voprosy: Monografiya [Civil Justice in Civil Matters: Urgent Questions: Monograph]. Moscow, 2010, p. 135. (In Russian) 
  Shakir’yanov R.V. Proizvodstvo po peresmotru postanovlenii mirovykh sudei po grazhdanskim delam v apellyatsionnom poryadke [Review of Magistrates Decisions in Civil Cases on Appeal]: Dissertation … Candidate of Legal Sciences. Saratov, 2006, p. 90. (In Russian) 
  Fal’kovich M.S. Osobennosti pred’yavleniya vstrechnogo iska [Features of the Counter-Claiming]. Sudebno-arbitrazhnaya praktika v Moskovskom regione. Voprosy pravoprimeneniya = Arbitration Jurisprudence in the Moscow Region. Issues of Law Enforcement, 2002, no. 1, p. 18. (In Russian) 
  Panteleeva Yu.A. Pred’yavlenie vstrechnogo iska v apellyatsionnoi instantsii [The Counter-Claiming in the Court of Appeal]. Arbitrazhnaya praktika = Arbitration Jurisprudence, 2010, no. 10, p. 116. (In Russian) 
  Prikhod’ko I.A. Dostupnost’ pravosudiya v arbitrazhnom i grazhdanskom protsesse: osnovnye problemy [Access to Justice in Arbitration and Civil Procedure: Basic Problems]. St. Petersburg, 2005, p. 450. (In Russian) 
  Kleinman A.F. Izbrannye trudy: V 2 t. [Selected Works: In 2 vols.]. Vol. 1. Krasnodar, 2008, p. 57. (In Russian) Yarkov V.V. Yuridicheskie fakty v tsivilisticheskom protsesse [Legal Facts in the Civilistic Procedure]. Moscow, 2012, p. 415. (In Russian). 

   Information about the author 

   Shakiryanov R.V. (Kazan) – Candidate of Legal Sciences, Judge of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan, Honored Lawyer of the Russian Federation (420015, Kazan, Pushkin st., 72/2; e-mail: [email protected]).

 el_.png   it_.png   book.png

R.V. Shakiryanov